American Yiddish culture’s center of gravity is most often located in New York’s Lower East Side. Caroline Luce makes the case for the Boyle Heights neighborhood of Los Angeles as an essential but often overlooked site. Her new book, Yiddish in the Land of Sunshine: Race, Labor, and Jewish Radicalism in Los Angeles (NYU Press), follows a cohort of young radicals from the edges of the Russian empire to Los Angeles, where they built unions, newspapers, and a Yiddish public culture in a city that sold itself as paradise and came down hard on dissent. We spoke with Luce about what LA promised them, where Jewish workers fit in the city’s labor history then and now, where she found sources no one had translated, and why so few people have told this story.
What was your main goal with this book?
The most fundamental project of this book is to reorient our map of the Yiddish world and add LA as a hub. The most basic intervention I’m trying to make is to honor the West as a site of Jewish experience, Jewish culture and Jewish community organizing, in a way that hasn’t really been done.
What did the Land of Sunshine promise the young Yiddish-speaking radicals who came here?
Caroline Luce: “Land of sunshine” is their phrase. They called LA Sunland, or the land of eternal sun. It was also the title of the Chamber of Commerce’s promotional magazine at the end of the 19th century, as LA boosted itself into existence. In the 19th century it looked like San Francisco would be the city of the West, so the people who had acquired massive amounts of land and those who stood to gain from the city’s growth formed booster organizations. They sold LA not as a Wild West but as a settled, peaceful one, with a romanticized Spanish past that, as Bill Deverell and Phoebe Kropp have shown, cast Anglo-Americans as heirs to the padres and the dons. You can still see that Spanish fantasy past in every vestigial bell tower on a building with no bell in it.
These radicals absorbed that romantic image. They came west for the same reasons everyone else did. In essence, what I write about is how they achieved the dream they were promised. Boyle Heights was 80 percent single-family homes. A union garment worker could afford a house with an orange tree in the backyard, maybe a car. They could go on picnics and send their kids to Yiddish school. They achieved that good life, and at times I think it limited their solidarity, or at least constrained their vision.
Having lived in LA for almost 20 years, I see that as a real phenomenon of LA living. This city will break your heart. The poverty and despair can be overwhelming. Then you spend some time in Brentwood and think, “this is paradise.” Most of these people had already spent five or ten years somewhere else, often on the East Coast, before coming to LA, and LA prompted a second recalibration of their affinities and solidarities. There wasn’t one response. I wanted to surface the varieties of radicalism rather than present one party line.
LA had both a Bund and the Partido Liberal Mexicano. What did Jewish and Mexican radicals see in each other?
In 1905, right at the height of the revolution in Russia, a chapter of the Bund pops up in LA’s English-language socialist newspaper. The Bund was a socialist Jewish organization that wanted to make the Jewish working class a vanguard of revolution against the czar. I can’t say whether the LA group was officially a chapter, because “Bund” can also just mean union. But there’s an amazing letter in the socialist paper from a comrade in prison in Slutsk, writing to a friend in LA: come join us, you’ll be revived, you’re living in the land of the dead. There were only a couple hundred Yiddish-speaking Eastern European Jews in LA then. The Bund was a horizon for them, a way to work out where they sat in this new place.
Into that comes a group of exiled radicals from Mexico, led by the Flores Magón brothers. Under Porfirio Díaz, land was taken, mostly from Indigenous communities, and handed to foreign investors. Collis Huntington laid 12,000 miles of railroad track in Mexico. Edward Doheny, who made his oil fortune in LA, came to control 85 percent of Mexico’s oil production. The Flores Magóns started as liberal reformers, were chased through Texas, St. Louis and Canada by Díaz’s private detectives, and radicalized along the way, fusing the communal self-governance of the ejidos with Kropotkin’s anarchism. They arrived in LA in 1907 and were promptly arrested and threatened with extradition. That case captured the whole radical movement. Emma Goldman came to town. Eugene Debs came to town. The socialist press called Díaz the czar of Mexico, and the Americans complicit in his rule were people every Angeleno knew. It connected the resistance to the czar they had been drawn to with their own local community. Their Bund chapter became a way to carve out a Jewish space in the local radical movement and a local space in the international Jewish movement.
The peak is May Day 1909. The Bund hosts it, 3,000 people turn out, and there are speeches in Hungarian, Russian, Yiddish, Spanish and Italian. The local socialist paper called it the most brilliant internationalist May Day in LA’s history. What follows is the 1910 bombing of the Los Angeles Times and brutal repression. That moment gave LA its reputation as an anti-union backwater. I try to show that it wasn’t for lack of trying. There was real internationalism, real radicalism, and it was squashed deliberately. Anti-picketing and anti–street speaking laws made it nearly impossible to organize downtown, which is part of why these radicals retreated into Boyle Heights.
Where did Jewish workers and organizers matter most to LA’s labor movement?
As elsewhere, Jews took up the trades they had access to in Eastern Europe, where the Russian imperial state kept them out of industry: no steel mills, no mines. They were concentrated in trades mechanization hadn’t reached yet: tailors, shoemakers, bakers, tanners. So, as in New York, immigrants in LA were heavily concentrated in garment, and also worked as bakers, carpenters and painters.
But industrialization came late to LA. Auto and steel don’t really arrive until the 1930s. Before that, the economy was based in colonial settlement, so timber, railroad, metal trades and garment workers, mostly producing for the local market. That meant a racialized dual labor system. Black and brown workers did the day labor, at what some employers called “the Mexican wage.” A smaller group of skilled, often unionized workers were, to get back to the land of sunshine, living a pretty great life. Employers boasted that their workers all owned their own homes; critics pointed out that a mortgage is a debt that keeps you from quitting your job. That dream depended on the labor of Black and brown people who weren’t getting those wages.
I think that’s still true of Los Angeles. Our comfort relies on the labor of Black and brown people we hardly ever see. I’m a bus rider. My bus to UCLA is grad students and brown women going to work in homes along the way.
You’re a labor historian at IRLE and an organizer with UC-AFT. Where are Jews in LA’s labor movement today?
Because industrialization came later here, Jewish upward mobility coincided with it. One of my favorite examples is Pinches Karl, a Bundist shoemaker from Łódź who opened a shoe store downtown around 1908 and grew it into Karl’s Shoes, with something like 28 locations. By 1928 he’s living in a mansion in Santa Monica, still going back to Boyle Heights for Bund events. In his memoir he insists he never changed. Okay, Pinches.
Some of the next generation stayed committed radicals and deliberately skipped white-collar work. Ben Dobbs became a machinist so he could organize machinists. My new project, Unjust Transitions, looks at the movement against plant closures in the ’70s and ’80s. Between 1975 and 1982, eight major manufacturing facilities in LA closed, and 75,000 union jobs were lost, half of them held by Black and brown workers. There are Jewish organizers all over that fight. Kathy Seal, who was at Barnard in 1968 and part of the student occupation, went to work on the line at a GM plant to organize, and when it began shutting down she called the meeting that became the LA Coalition Against Plant Shutdowns. They got an advance notice bill passed in California, championed by Maxine Waters.
The popular imagination is that the labor movement died with those plants. In LA something else happened: an embrace of immigrant workers that starts in the ’70s. The ILGWU becomes the first union to call for amnesty for undocumented immigrants, and organizers take on sectors dismissed as not the real labor movement, like garment shops and laundries raided by the INS.
And there are Jews all over that movement. A friend of mine said that it’s only our romanticized image of labor, guys in steel-toed boots, that makes us presume there are no Jews in it. UFCW 770, which organizes grocery workers, has Jews all over it. The writers’ strike, one of the biggest strikes in LA in the past five years, was full of Jews. I organize in academia, and some of the best organizers I know are Jews. There’s no longer a sector like garment, where at one point 75 percent of the workforce was Jewish. That doesn’t mean Jews aren’t active. Maybe we need to rethink how we perceive the labor movement before we can have a conversation about what the Jewish labor movement is.
Your book rests on Yiddish sources that hadn’t been translated. Where did you find them, and what shape were they in?
A lot of the material is still in New York, at YIVO and the Dorot Jewish Division of the New York Public Library. It meant something to send your papers to New York, the center of American Jewish life, but that makes it very hard for people on the West Coast to get to. At UCLA we were lucky to have a prolific acquisitions librarian, David Hirsch, who built a robust Yiddish collection. If it was bound and published, UCLA has it. Many of these books were published by groups of friends, and the local Yiddish press struggled to survive. The book has a chart of all the publications that exist as only one or two issues, and many don’t survive at all.
I also rely on souvenir booklets, almost like yearbooks, published for anniversary dinners. They’re hagiographic, but sometimes they’re my only source for when someone was born, where they lived, what they did. And on Yizkor books, the memorial books Holocaust survivors wrote about their hometowns, which often included maps. On a trip to Belarus and Poland in 2017, in Smorgon, I think, we were given a map from a Yizkor book and sent to find as many sites as we could. We found every one. When we did our Boyle Heights exhibit, we put a map of the neighborhood on the floor and watched elders find their school and walk home on it. If you’d asked them their address, they probably couldn’t have told you.
So my book has five custom maps, because LA’s landscape has changed beyond recognition. Six freeways were built in and around Boyle Heights between 1943 and 1960. The first time I went looking for the Bakers’ Hall on East 1st Street, the hall of the union I wrote my dissertation about, I turned the corner and it was the freeway. They just paved over the world these people created.
Besides your book, what should people read if they want to understand Jewish Los Angeles history?
First, Shari Rabin’s Jews on the Frontier, a lovely account of 19th-century Jewish history that centers mobility and asks how you practice Judaism in far-flung communities. It’s foundational for me.
There aren’t a lot of good histories of Jewish LA, so I’ll recommend fiction. Nathanael West’s The Day of the Locust is an amazing, vivid portrait of 1930s LA by a writer I first assumed was a blue-blooded Yale man. He was Jewish and had changed his name.
And Upton Sinclair’s Oil! People know it as the basis for There Will Be Blood, but the film uses only the beginning and end of a 500-page book. The book is really about the oilman’s son, Bunny, who goes to a university that’s basically USC and falls in with a crowd of Jewish socialists. Chaim Shapiro, one of the people in my book, ran for lieutenant governor on the Socialist ticket with Sinclair in 1930, and I’m convinced the Jewish socialist Bunny meets is based on him. Sinclair largely writes these Jewish socialists out of his own accounts of his life. But in his archive at Indiana University I found letters from Chaim to Sinclair, signed “Forever your lieutenant.” I’ll go to my grave believing that character is Chaim.
Caroline Luce is Project Director of the Memory Work Research Initiative at the UCLA Institute for Research on Labor and Employment and former Chief Curator of Mapping Jewish Los Angeles at the UCLA Alan D. Leve Center for Jewish Studies. Yiddish in the Land of Sunshine: Race, Labor, and Jewish Radicalism in Los Angeles is out now from NYU Press.
